Article
Amendments to legislation concerning enforcement of creditors’ rights and legal interests in bankruptcy cases of legal entities

The amendments to the federal laws as of 08.02.1998 №14-FL «On limited liability companies», 08.08.2001 №129-FL «On incorporation of legal entities and sole entrepreneurs», 26.10.2002 №127-FL «On insolvency (bankruptcy)» were introduced by the federal law as of 28.12.2016 №488-FL «On introduction of amendments to certain legislative acts of the Russian Federation».

In summary the introductions come to the following regulations.

1. Removal of limited liability company (LLC) from the Unified State Register of Legal Entities (EGRUL) in the manner established for inactive legal entities leads to refusal of the primary debtor to meet obligations. It is introduced in the Civil Code of the Russian Federation. If such refusal occurred due to the fact that persons representing the legal entity (collegial body members or identifying the activities of legal entity) acted against all sense or in bad faith, the subsidiary responsibility is laid on such persons for obligations of this legal entity upon application of the creditor.

2. Liquidation term of LLC (by the decision of its members or units that made decision on liquidation) shouldn’t exceed 1 year. The term may be extended no longer than for 6 months only in a judicial procedure.

3. From now on the EGRUL will include the following data:

  • - on commencement of bankruptcy proceedings of legal entity,
  • - on procedures carried out in bankruptcy proceedings in relation to legal entity.

The amendments introduce the procedure of making these entries in the EGRUL as well.

4. It is forbidden to make decision on the forthcoming striking-off of the legal entity from the EGRUL when the registration unit has the following data:

  • - on commencement of bankruptcy proceedings,
  • - on carried out procedures in bankruptcy proceedings.

5. The same procedure of the legal entity removal from the EGRUL is used in the following cases:

  • - inability to liquidate the legal entity due to lack of money for liquidation expenses,
  • - inability to fix shareholders or other members with such expenses,
  • - availability in the EGRUL of the data with an entry concerning its corruption, during more than 6 months from the moment of making such an entry.

Amendments were as well introduced into the procedure of bringing to the subsidiary responsibility of persons controlling the debtor.

The law comes into effect on the expiry of 180 days from the day of its official publication, excluding several particular provisions.

According to experts, the adopted measures on enforcement of creditors’ rights and legal interests in bankruptcy cases of legal entities take on particular relevance currently due to the fact that following the results of 2016 the number of liquidated companies in Russia goes beyond newly established by record 282 th. According to the Federal Tax Service of the RF, this significant amount was recorded for the first time throughout data collection in the EGRUL.

For more on – see our publication “Decreasing number of companies in the Unified State Register of Legal Entities” in the Credinform Newsletter.

Ranking
Product profitability of the largest Russian household electrical appliances manufacturers

Information agency Credinform prepared a ranking of product profitability of the largest Russian household electrical appliances manufacturers. The Russian manufacturers (Top-10) with the highest volume of revenue were selected for this ranking according to the data from the Statistical Register for the latest available periods (2015 and 2014). The enterprises were ranked by decrease in product profitability (see table 1).

Product profitability is sales revenue to expenses from ordinary activities. Profitability in general indicates the economic efficiency of production. Analysis of product profitability allows to conclude about an output expediency. There is no standard value for profitability indicators, because they change in accordance with the industry the company operates in.

For the most complete and objective view of the financial condition of the enterprise it is necessary to pay attention to the complex of presented ratios, financial and other indicators of the company.

Table 1. Net profit, revenue, product profitability and solvency index Globas-i® of the largest Russian household electrical appliances manufacturers (Top-10)
Name, INN, regionNet profit 2015, mln RUBRevenue 2015, mln RUBRevenue 2015 to 2014, +/- %Product profitability, %Solvency index GLOBAS-i®
LLC BEKO
INN 7804157910 Vladimir region
1 191,5 9 577,3 3 30,18 168
The highest
LLC ARISTON THERMO RUS
INN 4703066115 Leningrad region
947,1 5 397,4 4 26,36 162
The highest
LLC CONCERN AXION
INN 1831168300 the Republic of Udmurtia
-40,1 972,4 165 24,52 276
High
HEATING EQUIPMENT LTD
INN 4716025405 Leningrad region
48,2 1 914,0 10 24,50 257
High
LLC LG ELECTRONICS RUS
INN 5075018950 Moscow region
2 470,7 80 695,4 -17 10,32 224
High
JSC Krasnoyarsk Refrigerator Plant Biryusa
INN 2451000695 Krasnoyarsk territory
83,4 3 961,8 31 9,29 203
High
JSC "Production Association "Zavod imeni Sergo"
INN 1648032420 the Republic of Tatarstan
415,7 9 941,9 69 6,09 171
The highest
OOO BSH BYTOWIJE PRIBORY
INN 7819301797 Saint-Petersburg
-531,0 10 118,2 26 4,53 314
Satisfactory
PJSC VESTA
INN 4346047144 Kirov region
69,2 3 414,8 66 4,08 225
High
JSC INDESIT INTERNATIONAL
INN 4823005682 Lipetsk region
279,6 16 473,4 1 3,76 248
High
Total TOP-10 4 934,4 142 466,6 -5 14,36*  
Total TOP-100 5 162,5 150 675,9 -4 8,58*  

*) - average value by the group of companies

Average value of product profitability of the Top-10 companies in 2015 is higher than of the Top-100 at industry average value of 10,19%.

Product profitability of the largest Russian household electrical appliances manufacturers (Top-10)
Picture 1. Product profitability of the largest Russian household electrical appliances manufacturers (Top-10)

Revenue of 10 largest companies in 2015 is 95% of total revenue of the Top-100 companies, speaking about high monopolization in this sector. The share of LLC LG ELECTRONICS RUS, leading in term of 2015 revenue, amounted to almost 57% of the Top-10 total revenue (Picture 2).

Shares of companies in 2015 total revenue of the Top-10, %
Picture 2. Shares of companies in 2015 total revenue of the Top-10, %

Nine companies of the Top got high or the highest Solvency index GLOBAS-i® indicating their ability to timely and fully fulfill their debt liabilities.

OOO BSH BYTOWIJE PRIBORY got satisfactory index due to being a defendant in arbitration proceedings on debt recovery and loss in key figures. Index development trend is stable. Credit guarantees are recommended.

Four companies in the Top (marked with red in Table 1) have decrease in net profit or loss in 2015, or decrease in revenue in comparison with the previous period.

According to the data calculated on the basis of the Federal State Statistics Service (Table 2), from 2010 to 2016 the figures of household electrical appliances manufacture in volume terms are not stable. Following the results of 2016, there is an increase in production by 8% in comparison with 2015.

Table 2. Manufacture of main products in volume terms, th pcs
Products20102011201220132014201520162016 to 2010, +/- %
Household washing machines 2 699,5 3 030,4 3 335,7 3 830,3 3 879,9 3 485,0 4 018,3 48,8
Electric water heaters 4 658,1 4 564,8 4 659,5 4 523,5 3 879,7 3 400,9 3 456,7 -25,8
Household refrigerators 3 555,8 4 101,5 4 316,0 4 113,6 3 723,4 3 118,3 3 291,8 -7,4
Electric lights for residential premises 318,7 1 550,6 1 656,0 1 964,2 1 982,5 1 474,4 2 301,5 722,2
Household electric hobs 1 539,7 1 516,5 1 463,1 1 165,7 946,8 1 195,0 746,2 -51,5
Household kitchen combined gas-electric and electric cookers 558,1 502,2 430,9 353,1 379,8 474,2 536,1 -3,9
Electric meat mincer 724,1 682,5 553,2 479,6 294,5 376,7 505,1 -30,2
Household microwave ovens 1 065,9 1 379,1 1 030,6 925,2 1 284,7 463,8 309,1 -71
Electric shavers 582,1 491,1 300,6 238,7 293,3 297,4 301,5 -48,2
Electric cabinet ovens (household electric oven) 45,5 37,6 24,2 14,7 14,2 36,2 89,9 97,6
Electric kettles and samovars 173,1 270,4 263,3 271,9 87,8 158,4 78,2 -54,8
Electric juicers 52,4 33,2 18,9 17,4 25,1 39,4 48,9 -6,7
Household fans 25,8 23,4 20,4 15,6 18,7 19,2 42,5 64,7
Household vacuum cleaners 231,5 111,4 60,6 51,8 55,1 17,7 13,1 -94,3
Electric irons 65,0 32,4 24,7 0,5 1,3 0,4 1,0 -98,5
Total 16 295,5 18 327,2 18 157,8 17 965,9 16 866,8 14 556,9 15 739,9 -3,4

*) decrease in production is marked with red and increase is marked with green in Table 2. Types of products are ranked by the volume of production in 2016.

The maximal stability from 2010 to 2016 was demonstrated by manufacture of household washing machines and electric lights.

Enterprises engaged in household electrical appliances manufacture are distributed quite evenly along the country. Mostly they are located in the industrially developed regions with infrastructure for hi-tech manufacturing. According to the Information and analytical system Globas-i 100 companies largest in the sector and with the highest volume of revenue for 2015 are registered in 35 regions of Russia (Picture 3).

Regional distribution of 100 the largest Russian manufacturers of household electrical appliances
Picture 3. Regional distribution of 100 the largest Russian manufacturers of household electrical appliances

The leading position of Chelyabinsk region is noticeable.